India’s Supreme Court has recently made a landmark decision affirming the entitlement of divorced Muslim women to alimony under secular law.
This ruling underscores the principle that alimony is not merely an act of charity, but a fundamental right for all women, regardless of their religious background.
The court’s judgment highlights the necessity for financial stability for women post-divorce, advocating practical measures such as maintaining joint bank accounts and shared ATM access within the household.
(Read Time: Approx. 4 minutes)
Topics Discussed:
- The Supreme Court’s stance on alimony transcending religious laws as a fundamental right.
- The court’s suggestions for ensuring economic stability in households by implementing practical financial measures.
The Right to Alimony: A Secular Standpoint
In a recent case, Justices BV Nagarathna and Augustine George Masih ruled against a Muslim man’s challenge to a high court’s decision that required him to pay Rs 10,000 (£93.5) monthly to his divorced wife.
The man argued that under Muslim Personal Law, his former wife was not entitled to alimony.
However, the Supreme Court clarified that the right to maintenance is enshrined in the country’s criminal code, a secular provision applicable to all married women, irrespective of their religion – divorced Muslim women share the same rights.
This decision came after a family court in Telangana had initially ordered the man, Mr. Mohd Abdul Samad, to pay Rs 20,000 (£187) per month following a petition filed by his ex-wife in 2017.
She claimed that he had divorced her through the practice of triple talaq, which was declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court in 2017.
In this practice, a Muslim man can divorce his wife by saying “talaq” three times.
It is commonly practiced among India’s Muslim community, most of whom adhere to the Hanafi Islamic school of law.
Upholding Women’s Financial Rights
The Supreme Court’s ruling emphasises that personal laws cannot override the rights granted under secular law.
The judgment reinforces the necessity of providing financial support to women post-divorce, ensuring their economic stability.
The court also proposed practical measures such as maintaining joint bank accounts and sharing ATM access to ensure that women within the household have access to financial resources, which is crucial for their independence and security.
Mr. Samad’s legal team argued that the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986, should govern the matter, suggesting that it supersedes the secular criminal procedure code.
However, the court dismissed this argument, stating that the entitlement to maintenance is a right that transcends religious boundaries, promoting gender equality and financial security for all women.
Summary
This ruling marks a significant step forward in securing the financial rights of divorced women in India, particularly for those belonging to minority communities.
It affirms that all women, regardless of their religious affiliation, are entitled to seek maintenance under the law.
The court’s recommendations for practical financial arrangements underscore the importance of ensuring women’s economic stability post-divorce.
For those facing similar challenges or seeking advice on alimony and financial support, it’s crucial to seek professional legal guidance.
Contact us today to discuss your case – call us at 01772 282768, fill in our contact form here, or message us on our 24/7 WhatsApp phone line.